The Plum Island Horror: More of a Bad Thing

About this expansion

The Plum Island Horror: More of a Bad Thing is a 2025 board game expansion for 1–4 players, with an approximately 180-minute play time.

A new eyewitness source has come forward with an account of the atrocities on Plum Island. Their testimony suggests that the events already known were only the beginning, revealing nightmares far worse than previously understood.

After reviewing the new information, the team behind The Plum Island Horror returns with an expansion filled with more of a bad thing. This additional content broadens the experience with new options, new challenges, and further ways to interact with the game’s locations.

• Three new playable Factions
• New Scenarios, including a significantly more difficult Nightmare Mode
• New Mutations, Search cards, Fate Cards, and Events
• Location manipulation and more

The new scenarios add fresh situations to explore, while Nightmare Mode substantially raises the difficulty for players seeking a harsher challenge. The added cards and mutations expand the range of information, threats, and events encountered during play.

Location manipulation introduces another layer to the expansion’s content, giving the places connected to Plum Island a more active role. Combined with the new Factions and scenario material, these additions create a larger collection of possibilities for returning players.

The Plum Island Horror: More of a Bad Thing delivers a darker continuation of the Plum Island story, pairing new eyewitness revelations with additional content for the game. If the original events seemed terrible, this expansion promises that the real nightmares were only just beginning.